Baude Defends Supreme Court in New York Times, Saying It Deserves 'Celebration, Not Condemnation'
![]() |
| The Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C. — six of its nine justices were appointed by Republican presidents. |
A leading conservative legal scholar has a message for everyone demanding Supreme Court reform: the court is doing fine — better than fine. In a guest essay in The New York Times on Wednesday, titled "The Supreme Court Deserves Celebration, Not Condemnation", University of Chicago law professor William Baude argues that the reform debate on both sides does not reflect reality.
The essay lands at a charged moment. After Democrats' sweeping victory in this month's midterm elections, the party has been exploring a package of reforms, while some conservatives have discussed adding justices. Baude says the left sees the conservative majority as an obstacle, while some on the right see rulings against the Trump administration as betrayals.
His answer is that both sides are wrong. "Under the circumstances of the second Trump term, the Supreme Court is doing amazingly well," he writes. "If anything, it deserves our celebration, not our condemnation."
Baude's evidence is the court's own record. The court that struck down President Joe Biden's student loan forgiveness plan has also ruled against the Trump administration in the past year on tariffs, the Federal Reserve and deportation. Six of the nine justices were appointed by Republican presidents, three of them by President Donald Trump himself — yet the court has repeatedly ruled against him. Adding seats, Baude writes, would be "court-packing by another name".
![]() |
| The nine justices on the bench during oral arguments. |
But the line that set off the internet was a different one. "But the best court reform would just be for the justices to try harder and do a better job," Baude writes, according to readers quoting the essay on Bluesky. Some first took it for satire. Others said the piece concedes that partisan activism and corruption have damaged the court's legitimacy and that justices probably need term limits.
Baude is no outsider to the debate. He is the Harry Kalven Jr. Professor of Law at the University of Chicago, who coined "shadow docket" and clerked for Chief Justice John Roberts. He served on President Biden's Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court in 2021, which produced a 294-page report. His published verdict: court packing is lawful but unjustified, term limits need a constitutional amendment, and the shadow docket admits no simple reforms.
![]() |
| William Baude, Harry Kalven Jr. Professor of Law at the University of Chicago Law School. |
The wider debate is not going away. Former President Biden proposed 18-year term limits, a binding ethics code and an end to presidential immunity for crimes in office. In October, New York Times contributing writer Kate Shaw urged Democrats to make court reform a top priority, and the Strict Scrutiny podcast's November 11 "Blueprint for a Better Supreme Court" debated a gift ban, term limits and immunity.
The court sits under a cloud: a 6-3 conservative majority, a voluntary 2023 ethics code with no enforcement, and gift controversies involving Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito. Baude's essay is unlikely to settle any of that — but its most-quoted line has ensured the argument stays loud.
Sources:
- The New York Times, guest essay by William Baude (18 Nov 2026, 5:03 a.m. ET)
- Bluesky trending feed and reader posts quoting the essay (18 Nov 2026)
- University of Chicago Law School
- William Baude, "Reflections of a Supreme Court Commissioner", Minnesota Law Review (June 2022)
- Kate Shaw, The New York Times (Oct 2026)
- Strict Scrutiny podcast (11 Nov 2026)
- Washington Post / reporting on former President Biden's court-reform proposals (2024)


