Meagan Day Tells the Left Wokeness Is Still Its Biggest Liability in New York Times Essay
![]() |
| Meagan Day, a senior editor at Jacobin, wrote that wokeness has never produced an effective political formation. |
Jacobin editor Meagan Day has told the American left that wokeness remains its biggest liability, in a guest essay for The New York Times that set off a fierce backlash from fellow socialists within hours of publication on Thursday 20 November.
The essay, titled "I'm a Socialist. Wokeness Is Still the Left's Biggest Liability," was published at 5:01 a.m. ET. Its argument is summed up in the Times' own description of the piece: "I've seen a lot of wokeness in my time on the left, and I've never seen it produce an effective political formation."
![]() |
| The New York Times published Day's guest essay on 20 November 2026. |
Day opens the essay with her arrival at Oberlin College in the fall of 2007, and draws on her years inside the socialist movement to argue that the culture she calls "Woke Beta" — the pre-2014 era of campus and online left politics — never built anything that lasted. She notes the incoming Congress includes six democratic socialists and nine more candidates endorsed by Senator Bernie Sanders, and warns the left not to squander what she calls its best opportunity in decades.
The essay lands in the middle of a wider post-midterm argument inside the Democratic Party and the left about what the election results mean. Democrats swept the midterm elections earlier this month, and the Times has run a series of pieces on the question, including cultural critic Catherine Liu's 12 November podcast interview, "Democrats Have Power Now. They Shouldn't Waste It on Woke." The paper's editorial board has described the winning candidates as "economic populists and cultural moderates," and Day's piece pushes the same debate further left — and further from the party's activist base.
![]() |
| Day opens the essay with her arrival at Oberlin College in the fall of 2007. |
The reaction from socialists on Bluesky was swift and unsparing. Critics accused Day of treating a term rooted in Black liberation as a punchline, with one widely shared reply arguing: "Anyone who uses 'wokeness' as a pejorative hates both worker liberation and Black people. You can't be a socialist and hold this position." Writer Moira Donegan mocked the essay's framing, noting that its critics were "enamored of the victimization they felt when a couple of kids were self righteous at a liberal arts college 20 years ago." Journalist Joan Walsh wrote that she would not read "Little Miss Oberlin's essay," while others pointed out that Day's account of the pre-2014 left never mentions the Supreme Court's 2013 decision gutting the Voting Rights Act.
Day is a senior editor at Jacobin, the socialist magazine, a Democratic Socialists of America member for 10 years, and the co-author of "Bigger Than Bernie: How We Go from the Sanders Campaign to Democratic Socialism" (2020). She graduated from Oberlin College in 2012. Her essay is the latest sign that the left's internal argument over identity, class and electability — dormant while Democrats were out of power — has returned with the party back in control of Congress.
Sources: The New York Times (20 Nov 2026); Bluesky trending feed and posts by named users (20 Nov 2026); Wikipedia (Meagan Day); Jacobin; The Dig.


