Fanfiction Writers Revolt as New Library Lets Strangers Catalogue Their Stories
![]() |
Fanfiction writers are in open revolt over a new Goodreads-style library for BTS fanfiction that lets anyone catalogue somebody else's story — three days after Archive of Our Own, the fan-run archive known as AO3, came back from a 17-day shutdown.
The project is A Bangtan Fanfiction Library, announced on 30 October, where anyone can add and import a fic to recommend it or talk about it: users can follow, track and shelve fics. Importing a fic means creating a card with metadata and a link back to the original — no complete story is copied. A "claiming" system lets authors reclaim a work already listed and manage it.
![]() |
That promise has not calmed writers. The debate erupted on Bluesky on Wednesday, 18 November: authors argue that the summary, tags and other metadata they choose for a story are part of the work itself — not public information for strangers to rearrange.
"My summary, tags, and other metadata are part of my authorial practice when I upload my fic to AO3," wrote @pigeon-grip.bsky.social. "I don't want a stranger linking my fic on this site with their own metadata and no centralized control." The same writer asked how the system would treat locked or erased fics — "It's not my right to upload metadata about it to another site."
The claiming system drew the most anger. "You can reclaim your work," wrote @sowoozoojoon.borasky.com. "But it's my work. It's another writer's work. Why do we have to reclaim what is ours?" @signechan.bsky.social asked how ownership would be proved for stories years old, and how faked screenshots could be stopped from seizing control of another person's fic. Others asked whether authors could opt out at all.
![]() |
The row is the aftershock of AO3's shutdown. The archive went offline on 29 October after a security incident and returned on 15 November. While it was down, copycat sites sprang up: ao3.life hosted 15,831,236 scraped works by 2 November and sold AI-generated audiobooks of them, shutting down after 2,000 takedown requests in a single day. Writers found deleted and archive-locked stories reposted without consent. "We just got AO3 back and now people are making me want to never post again," one writer posted.
The library's defenders say it is nothing like the scrapers: it links back to the original fic and never hosts the text. But writers say that misses the point: on AO3 the author controls everything down to the comments, while a catalogue hands that control to whoever gets there first. Goodreads works, one writer argued, because its baseline data comes from publishers and cataloguers — "not some random person who might edit or editorialize".
![]() |
For now the argument is unresolved, and the library has not publicly answered the questions about exclusion and ownership verification. But the shutdown taught fandom a hard lesson about consent — and writers are no longer willing to treat it as optional.
Sources
- Bluesky trending feed 18 Nov 2026 + @abangtanficlib.bsky.social announcement thread, 30 Oct 2026
- Bluesky posts 18 Nov 2026 (@pigeon-grip.bsky.social, @sowoozoojoon.borasky.com, @signechan.bsky.social, @nottoday3412.bsky.social, @definitionofily.bsky.social, @hubernie.bsky.social, @starlightnecro.bsky.social, @fansplaining.bsky.social)
- 404 Media (Samantha Cole) — “Vibe Coded AO3 Clone Site Down After Fanfic Authors Buried It With 2,000 Takedown Notices in a Single Day” (3 Nov 2026)
- The Mary Sue — “What sites are scraping AO3 stories?” (Nov 2026)
- Fanlore — “AO3.life” (15,831,236 works by 2 Nov 2026)
- Gizmodo — “Website Selling ‘AI Slop Audiobooks’ Shuts Down Following Fierce Backlash From Authors” (3 Nov 2026)



