Senate Passes BAAJA Permitting Reform 62–33 as Landmark Bill Heads to the House
![]() |
| The Senate passed the BAAJA permitting reform bill late on Thursday night, 19 November, by 62 votes to 33. |
The US Senate passed the most sweeping overhaul of federal permitting in decades on Thursday night, voting 62–33 to send the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) to the House of Representatives. The vote followed years of negotiation.
Forty-seven Republicans voted for the bill, joined by 14 Democrats and independent Angus King of Maine. Thirty Democrats voted no, with independent Bernie Sanders of Vermont and the only two Republicans opposed, Josh Hawley of Missouri and Mike Rounds of South Dakota.
![]() |
| Senator Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia, one of the bill's four authors, called the vote the moment "permitting reform in the Senate finally became reality". |
Four senators wrote the bill — Republicans Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia and Mike Lee of Utah, and Democrats Martin Heinrich of New Mexico and Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island — and introduced it on 30 September as S. 5653. It cleared cloture 73–25 on 9 November and advanced 70–27 on 16 November.
BAAJA rewrites four bedrock environmental laws — the National Environmental Policy Act, the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act and the National Historic Preservation Act — passed as an amendment to H.R. 2347, a House-passed tax bill used as the vehicle. It codifies the Supreme Court's Seven County v. Eagle County decision, narrows environmental reviews, sets binding permit deadlines, limits lawsuits against projects and reforms the electric transmission grid, while making data centres pay their fair share of grid costs.
Supporters say it will make building roads, pipelines, power lines and energy projects faster and cheaper. "Tonight, the passage of permitting reform in the Senate finally became reality," Capito said. Heinrich said the bill would "create more than 100,000 good-paying American jobs" and get "more affordable energy onto the grid faster". Independent analyses project household electricity prices falling 3–5 percent, saving families about $50–$78 a year by 2040, according to the Rhodium Group.
![]() |
| Supporters say the bill will speed up renewable energy and transmission projects as well as fossil fuel infrastructure. |
The opposition was bipartisan too. Critics warned the bill weakens environmental protections and favours fossil fuels. Senator Jeff Merkley of Oregon said more gas and fossil fuel projects would "open another floodgate for carbon that we won't ever be able to reverse". The Sierra Club, the Natural Resources Defense Council, the National Wildlife Federation, 17 Democratic-led states and the National Congress of American Indians all oppose it — the last over changes to Section 106, which governs consultation with tribes over sacred sites. Senator Maria Cantwell of Washington warned against sacrificing clean water, sacred sites and tribal sovereignty.
No amendments received a vote before final passage, including Senator Ron Wyden's proposal to ban data centres on public lands. Senator Raphael Warnock of Georgia, who voted no after backing the bill at earlier stages, said: "I had hoped that a robust amendment process could've addressed these shortcomings in the bill."
The bill now heads to the House. Some House Republicans object to the transmission provisions, a spokesperson for Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries said the bill "falls short in several areas", and Senate Republican leader John Thune said he did not know whether the House would pass it unchanged. Representative Sharice Davids of Kansas broke with Jeffries on Friday, saying she was working with leaders in both parties to fix the bill's provisions so it could pass. President Donald Trump voiced his support for the bill earlier this month.
Sources: US Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources; US Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works; The Wall Street Journal; Sen. Dan Sullivan press release; Sen. Jacky Rosen press release; Sen. John Barrasso press release; National Association of Counties (NACo); Washington Examiner; News9 (AP/CBS); Benton Institute for Broadband & Society; Radio Purple; Nacionale; Courier Georgia; Buffalo's Fire; Grist; Starzyk & Associates; Sen. Maria Cantwell press release; Sault Tribe Guardian; Philly Daily.


