Controllers Reject Duffy's Explanation for the Nationwide Ground Stop
Air traffic controllers are openly rejecting Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy's explanation for Friday's nationwide flight ground stop, disputing the Trump administration's account of the communications failure that affected an estimated 1.5 million travellers. The stoppage — only the third nationwide ground stop ever ordered — was the longest in 25 years.
Washington Examiner reporter Anna Giaritelli told CNN's Laura Coates on Friday night that she had spoken with 60 air traffic controllers. "None of them are buying what he said," Giaritelli said. The controllers questioned the timing in particular: the kind of equipment switch Duffy described does not happen on a busy Friday afternoon, she said — such work is done midweek, in the middle of the night.
Air traffic controllers at radar scopes in a dim control room.
At a White House briefing on Friday evening, Duffy blamed ageing infrastructure, saying overloaded switches and routers had produced inconsistent radar and communications data. "Our switches, our routers actually got overloaded with data," he said. "And because of that, we shut the system down."
On Saturday, Duffy added that the overload occurred while contractor L3Harris was replacing old copper wire with fibre at a remote FAA site in El Dorado, Arkansas, and said officials were investigating whether contractor error or a faulty router was to blame. CNN reported the FAA and the FBI were examining the router at an L3Harris laboratory, and that about 30 percent of the FAA's copper lines have yet to be replaced.
But the administration's own account has shifted. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, at the same Friday briefing, said new equipment and patches being installed had overwhelmed the older system — at odds with Duffy's emphasis on old hardware. Duffy also insisted the FAA's new $875 million AI system, SMART, had nothing to do with the failure, saying it was "not even plugged in" — even though the FAA said earlier in the week it would now use SMART across all 22 centres.
FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford said as many as 17 of the 22 centres were affected, though none "actually went dark". The FAA lifted the ground stop at about 8:15 p.m. Eastern on Friday, but the disruption carried into the weekend: more than 4,100 flights were cancelled on Saturday alone, according to FlightAware, while more than 3,500 aircraft were already airborne. Bedford expected normal operations by Sunday evening, while warning the ageing technology "will continue to break until we replace it."
An air traffic control tower against a clear blue sky.
A crowded airport terminal, with weary passengers waiting with their luggage.
The dispute has fuelled political fallout. Duffy used the crisis to renew his demand for $50 billion from Congress to overhaul air traffic control — a request the top House Appropriations Democrat, Rosa DeLauro, called a "ransom". New York Governor Kathy Hochul called for Duffy's resignation, saying serious lapses had become a pattern on his watch. Representative James Walkinshaw cited a September Government Accountability Office report warning of precisely this kind of disruption.
Investigators are still determining whether contractor error or faulty equipment caused the failure, and calls are growing for an independent investigation. Duffy has said he will hold people accountable.
Since this article was drafted, the FAA has published its first detailed account of the investigation. In a question-and-answer update on 15 November, the agency named a second site alongside El Dorado — a radar station in Amarillo, Texas — and said the data flood ran at 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds. L3Harris has pulled the routers from both sites to its Florida laboratory for diagnostics, with the FBI assisting. The root cause remains under investigation, and the FAA says there is no indication of a cyberattack.
Sources
— Common Dreams, 14 Nov 2026
— CNN, 14 Nov 2026
— CNN, 15 Nov 2026
— WorldAttention, 15 Nov 2026
— Opera News, 15 Nov 2026
— FAA, "Nationwide Ground Stop — Questions and Answers", 15 Nov 2026



